SXSW: Tagging 2.0

March 20, 2006

The panel on tagging was excellent. As tags and tagging comprise so many ideas, this panel did a great job of covering a little bit of everything so the attendee left with a better overall understanding of the topic. From SXSW:

“Tagging 2.0″ – is tagging (user-driven description of data on the Web) *THE* key element of “Web 2.0″? What new tools can help us organize an internet’s worth of information for our own use and to share with others? Tagging systems are taking off now, what are the issues for communities of users and for those just trying to make sense of their own stuff? This session will show what’s new with tagging and get insights from a variety of perspectives, from folksonomies to the Semantic Web.

The panel consisted of Adina Levin (VP Prod, Socialtext), Prentiss Riddle (Tech Evangelist, Shadows.com), Rashmi Sinha (Uzanto), Thomas Vander Wal (Principal & Sr Consultant, InfoCloud Solutions), and Don Turnbull (Asst Professor, Univ of Texas at Austin).

Here are the notes:

- Vander Wal coined folksonomy

- folksonomy proves its own point

- is tagging the key element of web 2.0?

- are we even at tagging 1.0?

- tagging becomes my own personal metadata

- questions we need to ask: are these systems usable beyond alpha geeks? are these systems useful beyond a few types of tasks or categories or information?

- what does it take to get us to 2.0? practice, practice, practice

- uses of tags

  • Re-finding information
  • Creating personal metadata – on desktop, web
  • The new command line
  • Are tags the gateway to the next PIM
  • Use tags as verbs? Buy, sell, print, *, **, ***, **** (rating system with stars); For:, user/tags

- weâ??re just scratching surface
- how does tagging help you?

  • a focus on users view, not systems; people centric view of data; linking users by interests
  • good for keeping track of things you already know about
  • learn about things youâ??re interested in but may not have a sophisticated vocabulary about yet
  • it may be more interesting to find a like mind than a resource recommendation

- issues with tags

  • tag spamming and gaming; tagging optimization business?
  • tags are explicit
  • tags are text and can be analyzed
  • tag fraud
  • implicit tagging is both good and bad – your interests change, you have lots of interests, you belong to lots of different groups
  • not all resources are identifiable – granular web pages, items â?? commercial products
  • tags as identity – who shares what and what does that mean?

- tagging interfaces

  • whatâ??s the best way to get people to tag?
  • how can interfaces teach us about tagging vocabulary?
  • how can exploring tags be fun?
  • how can re-finding info be easier?

- tag clouds are not the answer

- tagging has moved into the mainstream â?? washingtonpost.com, etc.

- moving beyond the early adopters

- we need to fix the re-findabilty problem

- more than a handful of sites are doing it the right way

- the folksonomy triad – object, identity, metadata

- the six dirty secrets of tagging

  1. itâ??s the content stupid
  2. ordinary people donâ??t get tags – tag clouds have too many words
  3. itâ??s the UX, stupid – when tagging systems work, its because a lot of attention went into he whole experience
  4. tags donâ??t play well with others – tagging systems are plagued with interoperability problems; delimiter wars; interoperation amplifies imprecision; hard to migrate tags across communities
  5. rich functionality requires rich metadata
  6. nobody wants real tags
  7. - simple keyword metadata
    - no control
    - no hierarchy
    - no syntax or semantics
    - minimal cognitive effort by the user

- people really want tagginess

- syntax and semantics

- consensus tagging

- hierarchical tagging – using dots or slashes; problem is who decides what the hierarchy is?

- faceted tagging – buckets of tags; place, language, event, topic, and people

- tagging is social – helpful to individuals and increasing valuable to the group

- tagging for shared research

- tagging is simpler than categorization â?? donâ??t have to find the single best tag, just tag with what comes to mind

- tagging and wisdom of the crowds

- there are four conditions

  • cognitive diversity
  • independence
  • decentralization
  • easy aggregation

- tagging represents more than anything on web the wisdom of crowd decision making

- the moment of tagging is you and you alone â?? this is why its superior to Digg, Slashdot, etc; does not influence at moment of tagging

- you can aggregate richer data than just rating

- creates ad-hoc groups

- lots of weak social ties

- conceptually mediated ties

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

keith bohanna March 21, 2006 at 9:46 am

Tom,

Really enjoying your series of posts on SxSW – comprehensive and to the point.

thank you, keith

Tom Markiewicz March 21, 2006 at 11:14 am

Thanks Keith. It has taken some time to get my notes all transposed to the web, but they should all be posted by this afternoon. I found SXSW to be extremely informative, so I hope this series of posts helps those who couldn’t make it to the conference.

Thien April 18, 2014 at 7:18 am

We will print barcodes for you at drop off. Just keep a tally sheet liitsng how many barcodes you need at each price. Keep two lists, if applicable, one for the items that you want to be 1/2 price on Monday, and one for the items that will be marked No Discount. Hang and Tag your items and bring your list with you to drop off. We will print your barcodes for you at that time.You can also order barcodes online to be printed at home and save the file to your computer. Put it on a thumbdrive or upload to a local print store like Office Depot, Kinkos, etc. and have them printed.

personal statement writing April 20, 2014 at 3:00 am

Good to see a talent at work. I can’t match that.

free online book reports April 20, 2014 at 11:49 am

That’s a clever answer to a tricky question

car insurance uninsured April 22, 2014 at 7:57 am

That’s a smart way of looking at the world.

life insurance quotes April 22, 2014 at 10:42 pm

These pieces really set a standard in the industry.

free car quote insurance April 23, 2014 at 4:40 am

I love reading these articles because they’re short but informative.

frogsareevil.com April 23, 2014 at 8:19 am

That’s a quick-witted answer to a difficult question

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: